Plain-spoken guides. Nothing for sale.

Start Here

Twelve Myths About Witches, Wiccans, and Pagans

Illustration of a glowing lantern

Most of what people think they know about witches and Pagans comes from films, old sermons, and half-remembered history lessons, and very little of it is true. These are the twelve mistakes we meet most often, each set beside what is actually the case.

They are gathered under four headings: who witches and Pagans are, what they believe and do, where it all comes from, and how people practice. Each answer is short, and each points to a guide that goes further.

Who witches and Pagans are

1. Witches and Pagans worship the devil

They do not. The devil is a figure from Christian theology, and Pagan religions have no place for him. The link between witches and the Devil was made by churchmen and lawyers in the late Middle Ages, who reasoned that anyone working harmful magick must have sworn service to the enemy of God. Our guide to the making of the witch traces how that idea was built. The horned figure honored in Wicca is a god of woods and wild animals, and he has nothing to do with it.

2. Witch, Wiccan, and Pagan all mean the same thing

They are three different kinds of word. Pagan names a family of religions. Wiccan names one religion within that family. Witch names a practice that anyone can take up. So not every witch is Wiccan, since many witches follow another path or no religion at all. And not every Pagan is a witch, since Druids, Heathens, and many others never cast a spell. Our guide to the three words shows how they overlap.

3. Any religion that is not Christian is Pagan

That is the old meaning of the word, and it was never a polite one. For centuries it was used for anyone outside the Christian faith, and later for anyone outside Christianity, Judaism, and Islam. Today the word, with a capital P, belongs to a particular modern movement inspired by the old religions of Europe and the Mediterranean. Hindus, Buddhists, followers of Shinto, and Indigenous peoples have their own names for their own religions, and it is respectful to use them. Our history of the word Pagan tells the full story.

What they believe and do

4. Witchcraft is a religion

Witchcraft is a practice. It can form part of a religion, as it does in Wicca, or it can stand entirely alone. There are Wiccan witches, Christian witches, and witches with no religious beliefs whatever. What they share is a craft: working with intention, natural materials, symbols, and timing. Our guide to what witchcraft is explains.

5. Witchcraft is about harming or controlling people

The witch of the old stories was defined by harm. The modern witch is not. Most spellwork is quiet and domestic: a candle for courage, a charm bag for a calm home, a small ritual for letting something go. Most witches hold to a clear ethic, and most think it wrong to cast on a named person without consent. Practitioners do disagree about baneful work, and we set out that disagreement fairly in our guide to Pagan ethics.

6. Paganism is against Christianity

Paganism is defined by what Pagans honor, not by what they oppose. Its concerns are the natural world, the seasons, the gods, and the ancestors. Most Pagans have Christian relatives and friends and get along with them perfectly well, and some witches are Christians themselves. A few people do arrive in Paganism angry at the religion they grew up in. That is a personal matter, and it usually fades. Our common questions page says more about combining paths.

7. Paganism is not a real religion

Pagan religions have deities, rituals, holy days, ethics, rites of passage, and communities, which is what a religion is. In several countries Pagan groups are legally recognized. In some places Pagan weddings are legally binding, and Pagan chaplains serve in hospitals and prisons. In the United States the pentacle is among the emblems approved for the headstones of military veterans. What Paganism lacks is a central authority and a single holy book, and it has never wanted either. Our guide to Paganism today describes the movement as it now stands.

Where it comes from

8. Wicca is an unbroken ancient religion

It is not, and most Wiccans are happy to say so. Wicca took shape in England in the 1940s and 1950s. It drew on much older things, including folk magick, seasonal customs, and ancient myth, but the religion itself is modern. The theory that a Pagan witch cult survived in secret through the Christian centuries was proposed in 1921 and has been rejected by historians. Our account of the birth of Wicca tells the story. A religion does not have to be old to be true for the people who live it.

9. Nine million witches were burned

The figure is wrong by a factor of more than a hundred. Historians who have counted the surviving records estimate that between forty and sixty thousand people were executed for witchcraft in Europe and its colonies between about 1450 and 1750. The nine million began in the eighteenth century as one scholar's extrapolation from the records of a single German town, and it was repeated for two hundred years. Other parts of the legend are mistaken too. In England convicted witches were hanged and not burned, and the accused were ordinary villagers, not the priestesses of a hidden religion. The real numbers are terrible enough. See our guide to the European witch trials.

How people practice

10. You have to be born a witch

Witchcraft is a craft, and a craft is learned. No bloodline is needed, and no inherited gift. Some families do hand down folk customs, which is a fine thing to have, but it confers no rank. Be cautious of anyone who offers an ancient family tradition as a credential, since such claims are easy to make and almost impossible to check. Our guide to kinds of witch has more on hereditary practice.

11. You must join a coven

Most witches and most Pagans practice alone. They have done so since the 1980s, when a wave of practical books first made it possible to learn without a teacher. A coven can be a real source of friendship and training, but it is one way of practicing and not a requirement. A solitary practice is complete in itself. If you do want a group, our guide to covens and solitaries explains how to look for one safely.

12. You need expensive tools and a certain look

You need neither. Folk magick was practiced for centuries by people with very little money, using what was in the kitchen and the hedgerow. A candle, a cup of water, and a notebook are enough, as our article on practicing on a small budget shows. As for the look, the pointed hat belongs to picture books. Witches wear what everybody else wears, and there is no witch uniform.

When you meet a myth in conversation

Sooner or later someone will repeat one of these to you, usually with good intentions. A few habits make those moments easier.

  • Stay calm. A myth is not an attack. Most people are repeating something they heard once and never had a reason to question.
  • Ask before you answer. A simple "What have you heard about it?" tells you which myth you are dealing with.
  • Offer one plain fact. A single sentence is enough. Wicca is a modern religion that honors nature. Witchcraft is a practice, and there is no devil in it.
  • Do not try to win. You are correcting a mistake, not converting anyone. Leave scripture and debate alone.
  • Know when to stop. You do not owe anybody an argument, and it is fine to change the subject.

Our article on explaining your path to family and friends has more plain words for these conversations. And if you believed some of these things yourself until recently, you are in good company. Nearly all of us did.