Paganism has no commandments, no confession, and no scripture that settles moral questions. Pagans are expected to work out what is right for themselves and then to answer for what they do.
That can sound like no ethics at all. In practice it is a demanding one. This guide sets out where Pagans actually find their moral bearings: the well-known Wiccan sayings, the older virtues of the ancient world, care for the living earth, and a small number of hard questions on which thoughtful people disagree.
No commandments, full responsibility
Most Pagan paths share a starting point. Nobody stands between you and the gods, nobody can forgive you on their behalf, and there is no doctrine of a clean slate. What you have done, you have done. The proper response to a wrong is to admit it, repair what can be repaired, and act differently afterward.
The other half of this is trust. Pagan ethics assumes that an adult can think through consequences and can be relied on to do so. It gives principles and expects judgment. People who want a rule for every occasion sometimes find this uncomfortable. People who have felt smothered by rules often find it a relief, and then discover that it asks more of them, not less.
The Wiccan answers
Wicca gave modern Paganism its two best-known ethical statements. The Wiccan Rede advises that you may do as you will so long as it harms nobody. The Threefold Law holds that what you send out returns to you three times over. Each has a guide of its own on this site, and we will not repeat them here.
Two things are worth knowing about them. They belong to Wicca, and witches and Pagans of other paths are not bound by them. And both date in their present form from the twentieth century. They are good counsel. They are not the whole of Pagan ethics, and the rest of this page is about what else there is.
Older virtues
The religions that modern Pagans look back to did not teach ethics as a list of forbidden acts. They praised certain qualities of character and expected people to grow into them. The same handful appears again and again.
- Hospitality. The duty to welcome and feed a guest, and the matching duty of a guest to behave well. The Greeks placed it under the protection of Zeus himself, and it is the first virtue that most Heathens will name.
- Honesty and keeping your word. In societies without written contracts, an oath was the most serious thing a person could give. Many Pagans still treat a promise as binding and are careful about making one.
- Courage. This includes the quiet kinds: telling the truth, admitting a mistake, and leaving a bad situation.
- Reciprocity. A gift calls for a gift. The principle governs relationships with gods and spirits as well as with people, and it is why offerings matter. You do not only ask.
- Moderation. The words carved at the temple of Apollo at Delphi advised "nothing in excess". Greek thought prized self-command and a sense of proportion.
- Reverence and duty. The Romans called it pietas: doing right by the gods, your family, and your community.
- Truth and balance. The Egyptians named it ma'at, the right order of things, which every person was expected to uphold in daily dealings. Followers of the Kemetic path, described in our guide to reconstructionist paths, still take it as their guide.
A caution is in order. The ancient world also accepted slavery, conquest, and the subordination of women, and no modern Pagan is obliged to admire that. The old virtues are an inheritance to be used with judgment. They are not a golden age to be restored.
Care for the living world
If the earth is sacred, then how you treat it is a religious matter. For most Pagans this is where ethics becomes concrete. It shows in ordinary choices about waste, food, travel, and what is bought and thrown away, and many Pagans are active in conservation where they live.
It also applies to the Craft itself. Herbs can be overharvested in the wild, crystals are mined, and offerings left outdoors can harm animals or become litter. A practice that honors nature while damaging it has gone wrong somewhere. Our article on low-waste witchcraft suggests practical habits.
Consent: the test in magick
The most useful single question to ask before any working is whether the people it touches have agreed to it. Magick aimed at yourself, your own home, and your own circumstances raises no difficulty. Magick aimed at another named person, without that person's knowledge, tries to make a decision for them.
That is why most witches will not cast a love spell on a particular person, and why many will not even send healing to someone who has not asked for it. The remedy is usually simple. Ask first, or turn the working toward yourself: your own openness to love, your own calm, your own protection. Our guide Magic or Magick? says more about what a spell should and should not attempt.
The hexing debate
Whether a witch should ever curse is the oldest argument in the Craft, and it is not settled. It helps to state the positions fairly.
- Never. Most Wiccans, and a great many other witches, avoid baneful work altogether. They point to the Rede, to the risk of being wrong about who deserves what, and to the effect that nursing a grudge has on the person who nurses it.
- Rarely, and in defense. Some traditional and folk witches hold that a practitioner who cannot curse cannot fully protect. They note that folk magick has always included both cures and curses, and they reserve baneful work for serious harm when ordinary remedies have failed.
- Protection is a different thing. Nearly everyone agrees that shielding yourself, cleansing a space, and binding someone from doing further harm are not curses. They restrain and do not punish. See our guide to cleansing and protection.
Whatever you conclude, some points hold on every side. Magick is never a substitute for the police, a lawyer, a doctor, or leaving. Anger is a poor state in which to make decisions. And a person who is in danger needs practical help first.
Honesty, money, and groups
Much of the real ethical trouble in the Pagan world has nothing to do with spells. It has to do with people who claim more than they know, or who misuse the trust placed in them.
- Be honest about history. Do not present a modern ritual as ancient, or a family story as an unbroken lineage. The Craft does not need the help.
- Be honest about results. Nobody can promise what a spell or a reading will do. Charging frightened people to remove a curse that the seller has just diagnosed is a very old fraud.
- Respect what belongs to others. Some religions and practices are entered only through their own communities. Taking their rites without invitation is a failure of the guest's side of hospitality.
- Use power in a group with care. A teacher or a coven leader holds trust. Asking students for large sums, for sexual contact, or for secrecy from their families is abuse. Our guide to covens and solitaries lists the warning signs.
A code of your own
Many Pagans eventually write their ethics down. It need not be long. Half a page in your Book of Shadows is enough, and these questions will give you a start.
- What will I never do, in magick or out of it?
- What do I owe to the people close to me, to strangers, and to the place where I live?
- When I have done wrong, how do I put it right?
- Whose permission do I need before I act on their behalf?
- Which three qualities do I most want to be known for?
Read it again once a year and change what no longer rings true. An ethic that you have thought through and can explain is worth more than one you have borrowed, and it is the only kind that will hold when it is tested.