Between about 1700 and 1940, educated Europeans fell in love with the Pagan past. They did not yet practice a Pagan religion. They wrote poems, founded societies, collected folk tales, and built theories, and by the end of the period those theories had produced a detailed picture of an Old Religion that was said to have survived in secret.
That picture was mistaken as history. It was also the direct inspiration for Wicca and for much of modern Paganism. This guide follows the main threads: the Druids, the Romantic poets, the folklorists, the occultists, and the scholars who reimagined the witch.
The Druids return
The revival began with antiquarians, the gentleman scholars who first measured the ancient monuments of Britain. In the late 1600s John Aubrey suggested that Stonehenge and Avebury had been temples of the Druids, the priests whom Roman writers described among the Celtic peoples. In the 1740s William Stukeley turned the suggestion into a confident theory, complete with imagined ceremonies. Both men were wrong by a wide margin. Stonehenge is roughly two thousand years older than the Druids. The association has never quite gone away.
Druid societies followed. One was meeting in London by 1781, at first as a kind of social club with ancient trappings. In 1792 a Welsh stonemason and poet named Edward Williams, who wrote as Iolo Morganwg, held a ceremony of bards inside a ring of pebbles on Primrose Hill in London. He said that its rites had been handed down from the ancient Druids. He had written them himself, along with a number of the old manuscripts that he cited as proof. His ceremony was adopted by the national festival of Welsh poetry and is still performed there.
None of this was religious at first. It was patriotic, literary, and convivial. But it made the Druid a familiar and admired figure, and the modern path described in our guide to Druidry grows from this root.
The Romantics and the love of nature
The second thread was a change of feeling. As factories and cities spread, poets and painters turned to wild landscape as a place of something close to holiness. In 1807 William Wordsworth wrote that he would sooner be a Pagan, raised in a creed long outworn, than live deaf to the sea and the wind. Keats and Shelley filled their poems with Greek gods. For these writers the old gods stood for everything that an industrial and respectable age seemed to be losing.
One god in particular kept returning. Pan, the goat-footed god of Greek shepherds, became the spirit of the English countryside in dozens of Victorian and Edwardian poems, stories, and children's books. A horned god of wild places was a well-loved literary figure long before he was a Wiccan one.
The same writers shaped a new image of the feminine divine. By 1900, poets and scholars were speaking of a single great Goddess of earth and moon who stood behind all the goddesses of antiquity, and some proposed that prehistoric Europe had worshipped her alone. Most archaeologists now doubt this, but the idea was widely believed for decades. Our guide to the Goddess and the God describes what Wicca later made of both figures.
Folklore and the nation
The third thread was the collecting of folklore. In Germany, Jacob Grimm, one of the brothers known for their fairy tales, published a huge study in 1835 that tried to rebuild Germanic mythology from peasant customs and stories. In the same year a Finnish country doctor, Elias Lonnrot, published the Kalevala, an epic stitched together from folk songs. Collectors across Europe followed their lead, often in the service of a new national pride.
They worked from an assumption that seemed obvious at the time: country customs were fossils. A maypole, a harvest doll, or a midwinter play was taken to be the worn-down remnant of a Pagan rite, kept up by unlettered people who had forgotten what it meant. In 1890 James Frazer built the grandest version of this idea in The Golden Bough, which traced customs from all over the world back to a supposed ancient religion of fertility and to a god who dies and is reborn each year.
Later research has not been kind to the theory of survivals. Many folk customs turn out to be a few centuries old at most, and nearly all were kept by people who were Christians in every sense. Our guide to the end of the old religions explains why the survival of a custom is not the survival of a religion. Even so, Frazer's seasonal drama of the dying and returning god runs straight into the modern Wheel of the Year.
Spirits, Theosophy, and the magical orders
The fourth thread was a hunger for direct spiritual experience outside the churches. Spiritualism began in 1848, when two sisters in New York State reported that a spirit was answering their questions with knocks. Within a decade, seances were being held in parlors across America and Europe. In 1875 the Theosophical movement was founded in New York by a group around the Russian writer Helena Blavatsky. It taught that all religions preserve fragments of one ancient wisdom, and it made reincarnation and karma familiar ideas in the West.
In 1888 a magical order was founded in London that set out to turn the old books of ceremonial magick into a working system, with robes, grades of initiation, and rituals built around the four elements. Our guide to learned magick describes the tradition it drew on. Its members included poets and actresses as well as occultists. One former member, Aleister Crowley, went on to found a system of his own and to revive the old spelling of magick with a K.
These groups were small, but they trained people in the practice of ritual, and they wrote things down. When Wicca appeared, much of its ceremonial form came from them.
The witch reimagined
The last thread concerns the witch herself. In 1862 the French historian Jules Michelet published La Sorciere, which portrayed the medieval witch as a peasant healer and a priestess of nature who led the poor in secret rebellion against Church and lord. It was written quickly and with more passion than evidence, and it was very widely read.
In 1899 the American folklorist Charles Godfrey Leland published Aradia, or the Gospel of the Witches. He said that it was the sacred text of a surviving witch religion in Tuscany, given to him by a fortune-teller, and that its followers worshipped the goddess Diana. Scholars have never agreed on how much of it is traditional, how much his informant composed for him, and how much is his own. Passages from it were later worked into Wiccan liturgy.
Then, in 1921, the Egyptologist Margaret Murray gave the idea an academic form. She argued that the people tried as witches had been members of an organized Pagan fertility religion, which worshipped a horned god, met in groups of thirteen called covens, and kept seasonal festivals called sabbats and smaller meetings called esbats. For some forty years her article on witchcraft in a leading encyclopedia presented the theory to the public as settled fact.
Wrong as history, fertile as inspiration
Historians have since taken each of these ideas apart. The Druids did not build the stone circles. Folk customs are not Pagan rites in disguise. No single prehistoric Goddess religion can be shown from the evidence. And the records of the witch trials, read in full and not in selected extracts, show frightened neighbors and forced confessions, not a hidden church.
Yet by 1940 every element of a new religion was lying ready: the Goddess and the Horned God, the coven of thirteen, the sabbats, the ritual circle, the reverence for nature, and the stirring story of an Old Religion that had outlived its persecutors. People believed that story sincerely, and it answered a real need.
It took one more person to put the pieces together and to practice them. Our guide to the birth of Wicca takes up the story with Gerald Gardner in the New Forest.
The revival's history may have been mistaken, but what it loved was real: the land, the seasons, the old stories, and the sense that the world is holy. Those are still good reasons to be a Pagan.