Plain-spoken guides. Nothing for sale.

History

Paganism Today: A Movement Comes of Age

Illustration of a ring of people gathered around a central fire

Modern Paganism is no longer a new arrival. In the seventy years since Wicca became public, it has grown from a handful of English covens into a family of religions practiced on every continent, with clergy, festivals, legal standing in a number of countries, and a second and third generation raised inside it.

This guide picks up where our account of the birth of Wicca leaves off. It covers the forces that shaped the movement from the 1960s onward, the revival of other old religions, the effect of the internet, and the arguments that occupy Pagans now.

Three movements meet: the 1960s and 1970s

Wicca reached North America in the early 1960s and arrived in the middle of a cultural upheaval. Three movements of the time recognized something of themselves in it, and each one changed it.

  • The counterculture. A generation that distrusted institutions was drawn to a religion with no central authority, no fixed creed, and plenty of room for personal experience.
  • The women's movement. A religion that honored a Goddess and was led by priestesses was unlike anything on offer in most churches. Feminist witches formed traditions of their own, some of them for women only, and Goddess spirituality spread well beyond Wicca.
  • The environmental movement. People who were alarmed by pollution and the loss of wild places found in Paganism a religion that treated the earth as sacred and not as a resource.

By the end of the 1970s the result was something Gerald Gardner would hardly have recognized: larger, more American, more political, more varied, and much less secret. In 1979 two American books, one a journalist's survey of the new Pagan groups and the other a handbook of Goddess-centered witchcraft, introduced the movement to a wide public.

Festivals, books, and the solitary majority

Two developments of the 1980s opened the doors further. The first was the outdoor festival. Weekend gatherings in fields and campgrounds let hundreds of people from different traditions share ritual, and they produced a common Pagan culture of chants, customs, and friendships that belonged to no single group. The second was a wave of practical books that taught readers to practice alone, with a rite of self-dedication in place of initiation by a coven.

The effect has lasted. Initiatory covens continue, and they guard their lineages with care, but they are now a small part of the whole. Most Pagans today practice alone or with a few friends, learn from books and from one another, and gather in larger numbers only at festivals and public rituals. Our guide to covens and solitaries describes both ways of working.

The old religions revived

While Wicca was spreading, other people were reviving particular ancient religions on their own terms. In 1973 Iceland gave official recognition to a fellowship devoted to the Norse gods, which gave it the right to conduct legally binding weddings. It is now the largest religious body in the country outside Christianity, with several thousand members.

In Lithuania and Latvia, where folk songs had preserved a great deal of older lore, revival movements such as Lithuania's Romuva grew out of the study of folklore. They were suppressed under Soviet rule and returned to public life as it ended. After 1991, movements devoted to the old Slavic gods appeared across Eastern Europe. In Greece and Italy, groups that honor the Olympian and Roman gods now hold public rites, among them a celebration of the founding of Rome each April.

These paths are described in our guides to Heathenry and to reconstructionist paths. Their members often have little in common with Wiccans. They work from historical sources, keep their own calendars, and may not practice magick at all. Some decline the word Pagan altogether, for reasons given in our history of the word itself.

The internet years

From the 1990s the internet did for Paganism what printing once did for other religions. A teenager in a small town could find information, and other Pagans, without a bookshop or a coven within a hundred miles. Discussion boards gave way to blogs and then to social media, where short videos about spells, tarot, and moon phases now reach audiences that no festival could hold.

The gains are real: more voices, more languages, and far less isolation. So are the costs. Invented history spreads as fast as the careful kind, confident beginners teach other beginners, and much of what is posted is there to sell something.

The internet also completed a change that had begun earlier. Witchcraft is now widely practiced as a craft with no religious frame at all, by people who would not call themselves Wiccan or even Pagan.

Recognition, slowly

Legal and civic recognition has come in small steps, and it differs from country to country.

  • Ceremonies. In some countries, including Scotland, Pagan celebrants can conduct legally binding weddings. Pagan funerals and naming ceremonies are increasingly familiar.
  • Chaplaincy. Pagan chaplains and visitors serve in prisons, hospitals, universities, and the armed forces in several countries.
  • Symbols. Since 2007 the pentacle has been among the emblems approved for the headstones of military veterans in the United States.
  • Counting. A number of national censuses now record Pagan answers when people write them in.

Prejudice has not disappeared, and many Pagans still keep their religion private at work or with family. But the panic of the 1980s, when Pagans and witches were accused of belonging to imaginary criminal cults, has not returned.

How many Pagans are there?

Nobody knows exactly. There is no membership roll, many Pagans prefer not to state a religion, and surveys word their questions differently. The figures that exist are indications only.

In the 2021 census of England and Wales, about seventy-four thousand people described themselves as Pagan and about thirteen thousand as Wiccan. Surveys in the United States suggest a million or more adults. In Iceland the Norse fellowship counts several thousand members in a population of fewer than four hundred thousand. What the figures agree on is the direction. The counts have risen in almost every country that keeps them.

The arguments of a grown-up movement

A movement with no central authority settles its questions by arguing about them. These are the main ones now.

  • History. Most Pagans now accept that their religions are modern creations built from old material, and that the story of an unbroken witch cult is not true. A few find this hard. Most find it a relief.
  • Respect for other cultures. There is wide agreement that some traditions can be entered only through their own communities, and continuing debate about where learning ends and taking begins. Our guide to traditions and paths sets out the principle.
  • Racism. Symbols from the Norse and Germanic past have been misused by racist groups. Heathen communities have answered by stating plainly that their religion is open to people of every background.
  • Commerce and the environment. A nature religion sits awkwardly with mined crystals, over-harvested herbs, and plastic trinkets. Many practitioners are turning back to what is local, home-grown, or already in the house, as our article on low-waste witchcraft suggests.
  • Belief. Pagans who honor the gods as real persons share circles with Pagans who are atheists and treat ritual as a kind of poetry. Our guide to how Pagans see the divine describes the range.

What comes next

The newest thing about Paganism is that it has a past of its own. There are now Pagans whose parents and grandparents were Pagans. Studies of Pagan families suggest that parents tend to pass on values, such as respect for nature, tolerance, and independent thought, more than fixed beliefs, and that they expect their children to choose for themselves.

The movement also faces the practical questions of any settled community: how to care for its elders, bury its dead, train its clergy, and look after its own records.

If you are beginning now, you are joining something old enough to have learned from its mistakes and young enough to be shaped by the people in it. Nobody is in charge, which means that the next seventy years depend on ordinary practitioners being honest, careful, and kind.

One caution belongs at the end of this story. The friendly modern meaning of the word witch is not the meaning that most of the world knows. Our next guide, witchcraft around the world, explains the difference and why it matters.