Plain-spoken guides. Nothing for sale.

History

The Making of the Witch: How Medieval Europe Imagined Her

Illustration of a crescent moon over an ancient burial mound

The witch who was hunted in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries was not a real kind of person. She was an idea, assembled piece by piece between about 900 and 1500 from classical literature, village folklore, and the theories of churchmen.

Nobody designed her. Each piece was added for its own reasons, and it was only when they were joined together that mass trials became possible. This guide takes the pieces one at a time.

What the ancient world handed down

Medieval Europe inherited three things from Rome. The first was a body of law against harmful magick. The second was a literary figure: the hag who gathers herbs in graveyards and calls up the dead, described in our guide to magick in the ancient world. The third was a creature of folklore, the strix, a night-flying thing like a screech owl that preyed on sleeping children. The Italian word for a witch, strega, comes from it.

Beneath all three lay a belief much older than Rome and found in most societies: that certain neighbors can do harm by a word, a look, or a secret charm. The Latin name for such harm was maleficium. This village fear is the oldest layer of the witch, and it lasted longest.

The night ride and the women of winter

A second layer came from popular belief in the Alps and the German lands. People there told of a supernatural woman who traveled through the dark nights of midwinter at the head of a great company. She was called Perchta or Holda, and churchmen writing in Latin called her Diana. She visited houses, rewarded the hardworking, and punished the lazy, and families left food out for her. Some ordinary people, most of them women, believed that they traveled with her in spirit while their bodies slept.

Related stories told of the Wild Hunt, a ghostly troop of the dead that rode on the storm, and of the dead and the fairies who lived on inside prehistoric burial mounds. Our guide to ancestors and spirits describes this older world of belief.

None of this was witchcraft. The night women were mostly kindly figures, and the people who claimed to follow them were not accused of harming anyone. But the stories supplied images that were later put to a different use: the flight by night, the gathering, and the female leader.

The early Church was skeptical

For several centuries the official position of the Church was that such things did not happen. The clearest statement is a text known as the Canon Episcopi, recorded about 900. It tells bishops that some women believe they ride out at night on the backs of beasts in the company of Diana, and that this is a delusion sent in dreams. The error to be corrected was the belief. The penalty was penance.

Early medieval law took the same view. Harmful magick was punished as a crime when damage could be shown. Killing a supposed night-witch was itself forbidden in more than one early law code, on the ground that no Christian should believe such a creature existed. About 1100, the laws of a Hungarian king said flatly that no inquiry was to be made into night-witches, because there are none.

Heresy and a new kind of trial

The change began with heresy, not with witchcraft. In the twelfth and thirteenth centuries the Church faced organized movements of religious dissent, and it developed a new way of dealing with them. Under the inquisitorial method, a judge no longer waited for an accuser to bring a case. He opened an inquiry himself, took testimony in secret, and worked toward a confession. From 1252, torture was permitted in heresy cases.

The heretics were also accused of a standard set of horrors: meeting in secret at night, worshiping the Devil, holding orgies, and killing children. The same charges had been made by Pagan Romans against the early Christians, and by Christians against Jews. When these charges were later moved across to supposed witches, the result was the witches' sabbath. Even the names came from hostile talk about Jews: the meeting was called a sabbath, and in some early texts a synagogue.

The theologians add the Devil

The last piece was a theory. The Church had long taught that the old gods were demons, as our guide to how the old religions ended notes. The university theologians of the thirteenth century and after worked out a detailed theory of demons and their dealings with human beings. On this account, magick had no power of its own. If a charm worked, a demon had done the work, and the person who used the charm had made a pact with it, spoken or unspoken.

This changed the nature of the offense. A person who harmed a neighbor by magick had been a criminal. Now she was also a heretic who had left God for the Devil, and it no longer mattered whether she had hurt anyone.

In the 1420s and 1430s, in the valleys of the western Alps, the pieces came together. Trials there produced confessions, under torture, of a secret sect whose members flew to night meetings, worshiped the Devil, killed children, and raised storms. Preachers and judges wrote the confessions up as fact. The night ride that the Canon Episcopi had called a dream was now said to be real.

The Malleus Maleficarum of 1486 did not invent this picture. It collected it, argued for it at length, and insisted that witches were mostly women. Our guide to the witch trials takes up the story from there.

The English witch: an old woman and her familiar

By the end of the sixteenth century the witch had a settled face, at least in England. She was old, poor, and usually a widow. She lived at the edge of the village, begged at doors, and muttered when she was turned away.

Two things pointed suspicion at women like her. Learned writers held that women were weaker in faith than men and more easily tempted. And village life supplied the occasion. A householder who refused an old neighbor a little milk, heard her curse under her breath, and then lost a calf had both a guilty conscience and an explanation. People with the least power were thought the likeliest to take their revenge in secret.

English belief added a detail of its own: the familiar. This was a small animal, a cat, a toad, a mouse, or even a fly, that carried out the witch's wishes and was fed with milk or with a drop of her blood. It appears in an English trial as early as 1566. Its roots probably lie in the folklore of household spirits that had to be fed to keep them friendly. Learned opinion turned it into a demon, and the mark where it was supposed to feed became evidence to be searched for on the body of the accused.

How people protected themselves

A belief this strong produced defenses, and they show how ordinary the fear was.

  • Marks on the house. Protective signs were scratched beside doors, windows, and chimneys, the openings by which harm might enter. Our article on witch marks and witch bottles describes them.
  • Rules of dealing. You did not accept a gift from a suspected witch, least of all food, and you did not let her have the last word in a quarrel.
  • Expert help. A family that believed itself bewitched went to one of the cunning folk, who would identify the witch and supply a remedy.

Churchgoing people practiced these customs for centuries, before the trials and long after.

An idea ready to be used

By 1500 everything was in place: the village fear of harmful magick, the learned theory of the pact, the imagined sabbath and the flight to it, and a method of trial that could produce confessions to all of them. The parts had taken six hundred years to assemble.

The witch of the trials was imaginary, a mirror for the fears of the people who described her. The men and women who died as witches had not done what they were accused of. Modern witches have reclaimed the word, not the thing, as our guide to what witchcraft is explains.