The Pagan religions of Europe did not end in a single moment. They gave way to Christianity over about a thousand years, from the fourth century in the Roman Empire to the end of the fourteenth century on the shore of the Baltic.
How that happened matters to modern Pagans, because it settles what could and could not have survived. This guide follows the change region by region, describes how conversion usually worked, and sets out plainly what was lost and what came through.
The fourth-century turn
In the year 300, Christians were a minority in the Roman Empire and had recently been persecuted. In 313 the emperor Constantine made their religion legal, and he went on to favor it with money, buildings, and privileges. Within a lifetime it was the religion of the court.
One emperor tried to turn back. Julian, who reigned from 361 to 363, had been raised as a Christian and returned to the old gods. He reopened temples and tried to organize the old cults into something that could compete. He was killed on campaign in Persia after less than two years, and he is remembered as the last Pagan emperor.
The decisive laws came under Theodosius I, who banned public Pagan sacrifice in 391 and 392. Nobody could legislate private belief away. What the laws removed was the public structure: the temple funds, the priesthoods, and the festivals. Some temples were destroyed, many were converted into churches, and more were simply left to decay. In 529 the philosophical school at Athens, the last stronghold of the old learning, was closed.
A thousand years, region by region
Beyond the old imperial heartland, conversion took far longer. These dates mark the official change in each place. Daily habits changed more slowly.
| When | Where |
|---|---|
| 313 to 392 | The Roman Empire moves from legalizing Christianity to banning public Pagan sacrifice |
| Fifth century | Ireland |
| c. 500 | The Franks, under their king Clovis |
| 597 onward | The Anglo-Saxon kingdoms of England, beginning with Kent |
| 772 to 804 | The Saxons of northern Germany, conquered and baptized by force under Charlemagne |
| c. 960 to 1000 | Denmark, Poland, Kievan Rus, Hungary, Norway, and Iceland |
| Eleventh and twelfth centuries | Sweden |
| Twelfth and thirteenth centuries | The peoples of the southern and eastern Baltic, largely through crusade |
| 1387 | Lithuania, the last Pagan state in Europe |
Remote districts could hold out long after the surrounding country had changed. The mountainous Mani peninsula in southern Greece is said to have been converted only in the ninth century, five hundred years after Constantine.
How conversion usually worked
The details differed from one kingdom to the next, but the same few methods recur.
- From the top. The usual first convert was a king. Baptism brought alliances, royal marriages, trade, and literate clergy who could run an administration. His people followed, out of loyalty or by command. In Iceland, about the year 1000, the national assembly adopted Christianity by a single decision in order to keep the peace, and at first it allowed private sacrifice to continue.
- Sometimes by force. Charlemagne's laws for the conquered Saxons made refusing baptism a capital offense. The Baltic peoples were converted in the course of wars of conquest.
- By replacement. In 601 Pope Gregory advised the missionaries in England not to pull down the temples but to remove the images, consecrate the buildings as churches, and let the people keep their feasts in a new form. Elsewhere, sacred trees were cut down and chapels were built in their place.
- By condemnation. The old gods were not usually dismissed as imaginary. They were explained as demons. That idea had long consequences, which our guide to the making of the witch describes.
- Slowly. For centuries after each official conversion, sermons and law codes went on complaining about offerings left at wells, trees, and stones. A kingdom could be converted in a day. Its habits took generations.
What was lost
What ended was organized religion: the priesthoods, the temples, the public rites, and the teaching that passed them on. Most of it had never been written down by the people who practiced it. The Druids taught by word of mouth, and when the teaching stopped, the knowledge went with it. The same is true of the Norse, Slavic, and Baltic religions.
Even for Greece and Rome, where a great deal was recorded, the living practice ended. We can read a description of a festival. Nobody alive was taught how to hold one by someone who had been taught in turn. Our guide to ancient Paganism describes how much and how little can be known.
What survived, and in what form
A great deal came through the change, though none of it came through as a working religion.
- Stories. The myths of Greece and Rome never stopped being copied and taught. The Irish, Welsh, and Norse myths were written down by Christian scribes centuries after conversion, who saved them and also reshaped them.
- Learning. Philosophy, astronomy, and medicine were preserved by Byzantine scholars and by scholars writing in Arabic, who translated and extended them. This body of knowledge returned to western Europe in the Middle Ages, as our guide to learned magick explains.
- Customs. Seasonal bonfires, midwinter greenery, visits to holy wells, harvest customs, and healing charms continued for centuries. The people who kept them were Christians and understood them as part of a Christian life. See our guide to cunning folk.
- Names. Four English days of the week, Tuesday to Friday, still carry the names of Germanic gods, and many place names do the same.
Customs are not a religion
Here an honest caveat is needed. The survival of a custom is not the survival of a religion. A farmer who lit a midsummer fire in 1700 was not secretly worshiping an old god. He was doing what his neighbors did on Saint John's Eve. There is no evidence that an organized Pagan religion survived underground anywhere in Europe, and the theory that the witch trials uncovered one has been rejected by historians.
Popular claims about the Pagan origins of holidays need the same care. The true stories are mixed.
- Christmas. The date of December 25 was fixed in Rome in the fourth century, and historians disagree about how much it owed to Roman midwinter festivals. The greenery, the feasting, and the Yule log come from northern midwinter customs. The decorated tree is a German custom of the last few centuries. See Yule.
- Easter. The festival is Christian and is tied to the Jewish Passover. Only its English and German names are unusual. In the eighth century the monk Bede wrote that the English name came from a goddess, Eostre, and nothing else is known about her. See Ostara.
- Halloween. It is the eve of All Saints, a Christian feast that settled on November 1 in the eighth and ninth centuries. In Ireland and Scotland that date met the old Gaelic festival of Samhain, and many Halloween customs come from the Gaelic season.
What this means for modern Pagans
The plain conclusion is that modern Paganism is a revival and not a survival. The thread was cut. What came through were materials: myths, names, customs, places, and a great deal of scholarship about all four.
Those materials are real, and so is what has been made from them. From the eighteenth century onward, people began to gather them up and to imagine the old religions back into life, a story told in our guide to the Pagan revival. Modern Pagans do not need to claim an unbroken line. It is enough to say what was lost, to honor what remains, and to be clear about what is new.