Plain-spoken guides. Nothing for sale.

Everyday Practice

How to Explain Your Path to Family and Friends

Illustration of two speech bubbles

Late summer brings a particular kind of worry. The family gatherings of autumn and winter are coming into view, and people who have practiced quietly all year begin to wonder whether this is the year to say something. If that is you, here is what twenty years of these conversations have taught me.

You do not owe anyone an explanation

I will begin with the part that matters most. Your practice is yours, and a private practice is just as real as a public one. If telling someone could cost you your home, your job, your safety, or your place in your family, do not tell them. Our article on practicing in the broom closet is written for exactly that situation.

Everything below is for people who have decided, freely, that they would like to be known.

Decide why you are telling them

Before you say a word, work out what you want from the conversation. Perhaps you want to stop hiding a shelf of candles from your mother. Perhaps you want a partner to know where you go at the full moon. Perhaps you simply want one friend to understand you.

Each of those is a different size. Most of the conversations that go badly are ones in which somebody set out to share one small true thing and ended up defending an entire religion. Decide what you want them to know, tell them that, and stop.

One sentence is enough

People do not need a lecture. They need one sentence that they can repeat to themselves afterward. These are the ones I suggest.

  • If you are a Pagan. "My religion is a nature religion. I mark the seasons, and I treat the natural world as sacred."
  • If you are a Wiccan. "I follow a modern religion called Wicca. We honor a Goddess and a God, keep eight seasonal festivals, and try to harm nobody."
  • If you are a witch. "I keep a practice of small rituals with candles, herbs, and the phases of the moon. It helps me to live deliberately."

Notice what is missing: history, theology, and every word that needs a footnote. If they want more, they will ask. And if you are not yet sure which word is yours, our guide to the three words may help you to choose before you speak.

Start from shared ground

Almost everybody already does some of what you do. They light candles on a cake, bring evergreens indoors in December, give thanks over a meal, and take flowers to a grave. Begin there. A person who has been shown the familiar part first is much less alarmed by the rest.

The Wheel of the Year is a good thing to show a curious relative, because nobody is frightened by a calendar of the seasons. So is a windowsill of herbs.

The three questions you will get

I have been asked a great many questions over the years. Three of them come up nearly every time.

  • Is it devil worship? No. The devil belongs to Christian belief, and he has no place in mine. I do not believe in him, so I could hardly worship him.
  • Are you going to put a spell on me? No. I do nothing to anyone without being asked, and most of what I do concerns my own conduct.
  • Is this a phase? It may be. People change. I can only tell you that it has made me calmer and kinder, and that I will let you know.

Answer once, kindly, and in an ordinary voice. The tone does more work than the words. Our common questions page has plain answers to a good many others.

What to avoid, and what to do if it goes badly

Do not debate scripture. You will not win, and winning is not what the conversation is for. Do not perform. Leave the robe in the cupboard and the dramatic announcement unmade, since the aim is to seem exactly as ordinary as you are. And do not ask for approval. Ask only to be known.

Sometimes it goes badly anyway. If it does, end the conversation gently and give it time. You might say that you can see they are upset, that you are the same person you were yesterday, and that you are willing to talk again whenever they like.

Then go on being that same person, visibly, for as long as it takes. In my experience, families are not brought round by argument. They are brought round by the slow evidence of a year in which you were kind, kept your promises, and turned up for dinner.

And if they never come round, your practice is not diminished by so much as a candle. It was never theirs to grant.