Plain-spoken guides. Nothing for sale.

History

The Salem Witch Trials of 1692: A Plain Account

Illustration of a colonial meetinghouse

In 1692, in the English colony of Massachusetts, more than two hundred people were accused of witchcraft. Nineteen were hanged, one man was pressed to death, and at least five more died in jail before the colony came to its senses.

Salem was small beside the European hunts, and it came late, when trials were already dying out in England. It is remembered because it is so thoroughly documented, because it ended in public apology, and because it has served as a warning ever since.

Salem at a glance

When
February 1692 to May 1693
Where
Salem Village, now the town of Danvers, and neighboring towns in Massachusetts
Accused
More than two hundred people
Executed
Nineteen hanged: fourteen women and five men
Other deaths
One man pressed to death, and at least five people who died in jail
Key evidence
Spectral evidence: the visions reported by the afflicted

The setting

The Puritans of New England believed that the Devil was active in the world and that witchcraft was a real crime, punishable by death under English law. More than a dozen people had been hanged for it in New England before 1692. What made that year different was strain.

  • War. The colony was fighting the French and their Wabanaki allies on its northern frontier. Refugees from burned settlements had come south, and several of the accusers had lost parents or homes in the fighting.
  • A legal vacuum. Massachusetts had lost its charter, and the new one arrived only in May 1692. For months there was no court with clear authority to try a capital case, and the jails filled.
  • A divided village. Salem Village was a farming community that wanted independence from the prosperous port of Salem Town. Its families were quarreling over land and over their minister, Samuel Parris.

How it began

In the first weeks of 1692, two girls in the minister's house, his daughter Betty, aged nine, and his niece Abigail Williams, aged eleven, began to suffer fits. They screamed, twisted their bodies, and complained of being pinched and bitten. A doctor could find no natural cause and suggested witchcraft. Other girls and young women in the village soon showed the same signs.

A neighbor proposed a piece of English counter-magick: a cake baked with the girls' urine and fed to a dog, which was supposed to reveal the witch. It is a reminder that the folk remedies described in our guide to cunning folk had crossed the Atlantic with the settlers.

Pressed to say who was tormenting them, the girls named three women at the end of February. Tituba was an enslaved woman in the minister's household. Sarah Good was a beggar. Sarah Osborne was elderly, unwell, and had stopped going to church. All three were people with little standing and few defenders.

Tituba, after hard questioning, confessed. She described the Devil's book and said that there were other witches still unnamed. Her confession persuaded the magistrates that they faced a conspiracy, and the accusations spread: to respected church members such as the elderly Rebecca Nurse, to a former minister of the village, and outward to more than twenty towns.

Spectral evidence and other proofs

The trials turned on kinds of proof that could not be tested.

  • Spectral evidence. The afflicted said that they could see the specter, or shape, of the accused person attacking them, though nobody else in the room could. The court accepted this on the theory that the Devil could not use a person's shape without that person's consent. An alibi was useless against it.
  • The touch test. If an afflicted person in a fit grew calm when the accused touched her, it was taken to show that the evil had flowed back into the witch.
  • The witch's mark. The bodies of the accused were searched for a mole or blemish where a familiar might feed.
  • Confession. About fifty people confessed. Those who did, and who named others, were kept alive as witnesses. Those who insisted on their innocence were the ones who hanged.

That last point is the bitterest. Every one of the nineteen people hanged had refused to confess to something that had not happened.

The court and the toll

When the new governor, William Phips, arrived in May, he set up a special court. It sat from June to September and convicted everyone it tried.

The first to die was Bridget Bishop, hanged on June 10. Five more people were hanged in July, five in August, and eight on September 22. Rebecca Nurse was at first found not guilty, until the judges asked the jury to think again. Giles Corey, a farmer of about eighty, refused to enter a plea, and the court ordered heavy stones laid on him to force one. He died after two days without giving in.

In all, nineteen people were hanged, fourteen women and five men, and at least five more died in jail.

How it ended, and the apology that followed

By the autumn, doubt was growing. A group of ministers, led by Increase Mather, argued in print that spectral evidence could not be trusted and that it was better for suspected witches to go free than for an innocent person to die. The accusers had also begun to name people too prominent to be believed, reportedly including the governor's own wife.

In October 1692 the governor halted the trials and dissolved the special court. A new court met in January and refused to convict on spectral evidence. Almost everyone it tried was acquitted, and the governor reprieved the few who were not. By May 1693 the remaining prisoners had been released.

What happened next is unusual in the history of witch trials. In 1697 the colony held a day of fasting and repentance. One of the judges, Samuel Sewall, stood in his church while his confession of blame was read aloud, and twelve jurors signed a statement asking forgiveness. In 1706 one of the chief accusers did the same. In 1711 the colony reversed the convictions of most of the condemned and paid compensation to their families. The last names were not formally cleared until modern times.

Why did it happen?

There is no single agreed explanation. Historians point to a sincere and universal belief in witchcraft, to the terror of the frontier war, to the feuds of Salem Village, and to the long legal vacuum. The fits themselves have been explained as real distress, as suggestion spreading within a frightened group, and in some cases as deliberate pretense. Probably all three played a part.

One popular theory can be set aside. In the 1970s it was suggested that the girls had eaten rye bread contaminated with ergot, a fungus that can cause convulsions and hallucinations. Most historians do not accept this. The symptoms came and went with events in the courtroom, and they do not match the pattern of ergot poisoning.

Accusations of witchcraft were common in the seventeenth century. What made Salem deadly was a court that believed them without proof.

What Salem was not

  • It was not a burning. The condemned were hanged, as English law required.
  • The accused were not witches. They were Puritan farmers, servants, and church members. There is no evidence that any of them practiced harmful magick, and none of them was a Pagan.
  • It was not typical. Salem was late, colonial, and brief, and it was repudiated within five years. The great European hunts, described in our guide to the witch trials, were far larger.

Why Salem still matters

Salem gave the English language the witch hunt as a name for any panic in which accusation is treated as proof. It shows how quickly a frightened community can abandon its own standards of evidence, and how hard it is to stop once confession is rewarded and denial is punished.

For modern witches the lesson is the one drawn from the whole history of the trials. The dead of Salem deserve to be remembered as what they were, and not adopted as ancestors of the Craft. Our guides to the making of the witch and to common myths correct other misunderstandings, and witchcraft around the world shows that accusations of this kind have not ended. The whole sequence of dates is set out in the timeline.