Plain-spoken guides. Nothing for sale.

History

The European Witch Trials: What Actually Happened

Illustration of a set of balance scales

Between about 1450 and 1750, courts in Europe and its colonies tried people for the crime of witchcraft. Historians estimate that between forty and sixty thousand were executed, and that roughly twice that number stood trial.

The subject is surrounded by legends, some of them cherished by modern witches. This guide sets out what the records show: how an accusation began, how the courts worked, who was accused, why the hunts stopped, and which popular claims do not hold up.

The witch trials at a glance

When
c. 1450 to 1750, with the worst decades between about 1560 and 1650
Where
Most of Europe and some of its colonies
Executed
Between forty and sixty thousand people
The accused
About three in four were women, though in some regions most were men
The charge
Harming others by magick and, in most of Europe, making a pact with the Devil

An idea and a procedure

Mass trials needed two things. One was the idea of the witch as a servant of the Devil, which took centuries to form and is traced in our guide to the making of the witch. The other was a court with the means to turn suspicion into conviction.

The best-known statement of the idea is the Malleus Maleficarum, first printed in 1486. Its author was Heinrich Kramer, a German inquisitor who wrote it after a local bishop had stopped one of his prosecutions. He prefaced it with a papal bull of 1484, and he named a colleague, Jacob Sprenger, as co-author, though Sprenger's part is doubtful. The book was never officially adopted by the Church. It was reprinted many times and used by Catholic and Protestant judges alike.

It was influential, but it was not the cause of the hunts. The worst of them came a century after it was printed.

How an accusation began

Accusations almost always came from below. They started among neighbors, usually after a quarrel. Then came a misfortune that nobody could explain: a child fell sick, a cow went dry, a healthy man died suddenly. Ill will followed by unexplained harm was enough to raise suspicion. A reputation for witchcraft could build for years, even decades, before anyone went to a magistrate.

Women appear among the accusers and witnesses as often as men, and much of the testimony concerns childbirth, young children, food, and the dairy.

Behind the local quarrels lay wider strains. The trials were at their height during the religious wars that followed the Reformation, in decades of failed harvests, hard winters, and plague. Historians disagree about how much weight to give each of these, and no single cause explains every hunt.

Two kinds of trial

On the Continent. Most courts followed an inquisitorial procedure and could use torture when there was enough evidence to justify it. Torture produced confessions of the pact and the sabbath, and the accused were then asked who else had been there. Each confession supplied new names. This is how single cases grew into panics. In the German cities of Trier, Wurzburg, and Bamberg, such chains of accusation killed hundreds of people at a time, including children, priests, and town councilors. The usual sentence was burning, often after strangling.

In England. Witchcraft was a felony under Acts of 1563 and 1604, tried before a jury, and the law did not allow torture. English trials therefore turned less on the sabbath and more on the harm done and on the witch's familiar. The convicted were hanged. About five hundred people were executed over nearly two centuries. The worst episode came during the Civil War, between 1645 and 1647, when Matthew Hopkins toured East Anglia as a self-appointed witch finder and kept suspects awake for nights on end. He is linked to more than a hundred executions.

Across Europe, small local courts with little oversight were the most dangerous. Where cases went on appeal to senior judges, as in much of France, death sentences were often overturned.

Who was accused

About three in four of the accused were women. Older women, poor women, and widows were more likely to be named than others, although once a panic was under way nobody was safe. The proportion varied by region. In Iceland, Normandy, Estonia, and Russia, most of the accused were men.

Two things are worth saying plainly about them.

  • Few were healers or midwives. Healers and midwives made up a small minority of the accused in most regions that have been studied.
  • The village magicians were rarely among them. The cunning folk, who sold charms and cures, were seldom prosecuted as witches. More often they were the people a frightened family consulted to find out who the witch was.

Where it was worst, and where it was mild

RegionWhat happened
The German-speaking lands of the Holy Roman EmpireAbout half of all executions. A patchwork of small states, each with its own courts, saw the largest panics.
ScotlandBetween four and six thousand people prosecuted, in several waves. Torture was used, as on the Continent.
EnglandAbout five hundred executed, by hanging. No judicial torture.
Spain and ItalyMany inquiries and few executions. The Inquisitions there were comparatively skeptical.
IrelandVery few trials. Unexplained misfortune was more often blamed on the fairies.

After a panic in the Basque country in 1609, the Spanish Inquisition sent one of its own judges to review the evidence. He reported that he had found no proof that any act of witchcraft had taken place. The Inquisition tightened its rules of evidence, and executions for witchcraft in Spain all but ceased.

Why the hunts ended

The trials did not end because people stopped believing in magick. They ended because judges lost confidence that the crime could be proved. Confessions made under torture were shown to be worthless, most forcefully in 1631 by Friedrich Spee, a German priest who had heard the last confessions of the condemned. Higher courts demanded better evidence, restricted torture, and overruled local judges. After 1700 prosecutions became rare.

The last executions in England took place in the 1680s, in Scotland in 1727, and in Europe as a whole in Switzerland in 1782. In Britain the Witchcraft Act of 1735 abolished the crime of witchcraft altogether. From then on, the offense was pretending to have magical powers. The law had stopped treating witchcraft as real and begun treating it as fraud. That Act stayed in force until 1951, a date that matters to the story of the birth of Wicca.

Legends worth letting go

  • Nine million dead. This figure began as an eighteenth-century guess, multiplied up from the records of one German town, and was repeated for two hundred years. The evidence supports forty to sixty thousand.
  • Burned at the stake in England. English witches were hanged, and so were those in the American colonies, including Salem. Burning was the practice on the Continent and in Scotland.
  • The Inquisition did it. Most trials were held in secular courts. The Spanish and Roman Inquisitions executed comparatively few people for witchcraft.
  • A medieval horror. The great hunts belong to the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, the age of the Renaissance, the Reformation, and the printing press.
  • A persecuted Pagan faith. Nearly all of the accused were Christians, as their accusers were. The theory that they belonged to a surviving old religion was proposed in 1921 and has been rejected by historians. Our guide to the Pagan revival explains how it arose.

Why modern witches should know this

The people who died were ordinary villagers and townspeople, most of them women, killed for something they had not done. Remembering them accurately honors them better than any legend can. Inflating the numbers, or claiming the dead as fellow Pagans, replaces their story with one about ourselves.

The history is also a warning that has not expired. Fear, a convenient scapegoat, and a court willing to accept bad evidence are still found together, and in some parts of the world people are still killed as witches, as our guide to witchcraft around the world describes.

When someone today chooses to be called a witch, they take up a word that was once a death sentence. Our guide to what witchcraft is describes what the word means now.