Wicca became a public religion in England in the early 1950s, and the person most responsible was a retired civil servant in his sixties named Gerald Gardner. He said that he had found a surviving witch religion. What he gave the world was, on any honest reading, a new religion made from old material.
Our short history tells this story in a few paragraphs. This guide tells it more fully: who Gardner was, what he claimed, what changed in 1951, who helped him, and what the religion was built from.
Who Gerald Gardner was
Gerald Brosseau Gardner was born near Liverpool in 1884 into a prosperous family of timber merchants. He was a sickly child who was sent abroad for his health, and he had almost no formal schooling. As a young man he went out to Asia and stayed for some thirty-five years, first managing tea and rubber plantations in Ceylon, Borneo, and Malaya, and then working as a government inspector and customs officer.
He was a curious amateur scholar who studied the magical beliefs of the peoples he lived among, collected ritual knives, and wrote a respected study of Malay weapons. He was also a committed naturist and a tireless joiner of societies. In 1936 he retired to England, and he soon settled on the edge of the New Forest, near the south coast.
The New Forest, 1939
Near his new home Gardner joined an amateur esoteric theater company. Among its members, he later said, he met a small group of people who took him into their confidence. In September 1939, in a large house belonging to a wealthy local woman, they initiated him into what they told him was a coven of the Old Religion, a survival of the witch cult that Margaret Murray had described.
That is Gardner's account, and it is the only firsthand one. Historians have tested it for decades and still disagree. It is possible that a group of friends with occult interests had formed a coven in the years before the war, inspired by Murray's books, and that Gardner was sincerely initiated into it. It is also possible that he embroidered a slighter experience.
What no historian now accepts is that the group, if it existed, was an unbroken survival from the Middle Ages. The theory that it rested on has been disproved, as our guide to the Pagan revival explains.
1951: the law changes
Gardner said that his initiators would not let him publish. There was also a legal obstacle, although it is often misdescribed. Witchcraft itself had not been a crime in Britain since the Witchcraft Act of 1735. That Act took the view that witchcraft did not exist. It punished people who pretended to have magical powers with up to a year in prison. As late as 1944 it was used to jail a Spiritualist medium.
Spiritualists campaigned against the Act for years. In 1951 Parliament repealed it and put a narrower law against fraudulent mediums in its place. Nobody had witches in mind. But the repeal removed the risk of prosecution for claiming to practice magick, and it put the word witchcraft back in the newspapers.
The museum, the book, and the newspapers
In the same year a former filmmaker opened a museum of witchcraft and folk magick on the Isle of Man. Gardner joined him as the museum's resident witch and later bought it.
In 1954 Gardner published a plain account, with an introduction by Margaret Murray herself. It presented witchcraft as a gentle and dying nature religion, and its author as a sympathetic observer who had been allowed inside. It was the first book to describe the religion.
The press was less kind. Sunday newspapers ran stories about devil worship in the suburbs, and Gardner's fondness for interviews drew them to his covens. He believed that publicity would keep the religion alive. Several of his initiates believed that he was endangering them.
Doreen Valiente and the words
The most important of those initiates was Doreen Valiente, who was initiated at midsummer in 1953 and soon became High Priestess of Gardner's coven. She saw at once that long passages of his ritual book, the first Book of Shadows, had been borrowed from published sources, including the writings of Aleister Crowley, and she told him so. Gardner replied that the rites he had received were fragmentary and that he had filled the gaps as best he could. He invited her to do better.
She did. Over the next few years Valiente rewrote much of the liturgy in plain, rhythmic English, cut the more obvious borrowings, and composed the best-known version of the Charge of the Goddess. A great deal of what Wiccans actually say in circle is hers. She parted from Gardner in 1957, in a dispute over publicity and over a set of rules that he produced, and she went on to research the history of the Craft with unusual honesty.
Other lines, and the crossing to America
Gardner was not the only person in Britain in the 1950s and 1960s to say that he practiced an old witchcraft. Others came forward with claims of family traditions, and some founded groups of their own. The most successful was Alex Sanders, a gifted showman from the north of England, who said that his grandmother had initiated him as a child. The evidence indicates that he was initiated into a coven of Gardner's lineage in the early 1960s. The Alexandrian tradition that he founded keeps the same basic rites, with a stronger flavor of ceremonial magick. Our guide to traditions and paths describes how the two lines stand today.
In the early 1960s an English couple living near New York were initiated into Gardner's line and founded a coven on Long Island. From there the religion spread across North America. Gardner himself died at sea in February 1964, on his way home from a winter abroad. By then there were covens he had never visited, led by people he had never met.
What the religion was built from
Scholars who have compared Gardner's early ritual texts with older sources have identified most of the ingredients.
- English folk magick and folklore. Charms, seasonal customs, and the lore of the cunning folk.
- Ceremonial magick. The cast circle, the consecrated tools, and the calling of the four quarters come from the grimoires and from the magical orders of the nineteenth century. See our guide to learned magick.
- Margaret Murray's theory. The coven of thirteen, the Horned God, the sabbats and esbats, and the name Old Religion.
- Poetry and literature. Lines from Leland's Aradia, from Crowley, and from a poem by Rudyard Kipling all found their way into the rites.
- Fraternal ritual. Three degrees of initiation, oaths of secrecy, and working tools presented to the candidate follow a pattern that was familiar from the fraternal lodges of the day.
- Gardner's own tastes. Ritual nudity reflects his naturism, and his long interest in ritual knives may help to explain the importance of the athame.
The calendar grew in the same way. Gardner's first covens kept four seasonal festivals. The solstices and equinoxes were added in the late 1950s to make the eight sabbats of the Wheel of the Year.
A new religion from old material
It is sometimes said that all this makes Wicca a fake. That does not follow. Every religion has a beginning, and most have founders who combined what they inherited with what they saw for themselves. What matters is whether the result is honest about itself and good for the people who practice it.
On honesty, the Craft has improved with age. Gardner told his story as he wished it to be. Doreen Valiente and later generations of Wiccans chose to check it, and today most initiates will tell you plainly that their religion took shape in the twentieth century.
The honest description is the one we use throughout this site: a new religion made from old material. The moon, the seasons, the herbs, and the old gods are ancient. The circle that gathers them was drawn in the 1950s by a small group of people in England, one of whom could not stop talking about it. Our guide to Paganism today follows what happened once the rest of the world began to listen.