Plain-spoken guides. Nothing for sale.

Moon and Divination

From Bird Flight to Tarot: A Very Short History of Divination

Illustration of three birds in flight

Somebody told me last month, with complete confidence, that tarot cards were carried out of Egypt by priests who had hidden their secret wisdom in a pack of playing cards. It is a lovely story. It is also less than two hundred and fifty years old, and it was made up in Paris.

I have read cards since 2011, and I think the true history of divination is better than the legend. Here it is, as briefly as I can tell it.

Reading the world

The oldest kinds of divination needed no tools. They read the world as it was. In ancient Mesopotamia, specialists kept careful records of omens for centuries, and they looked for signs in the sky, in dreams, and in the organs of animals offered at the temple.

In Rome, officials called augurs watched the flight and the calls of birds before any important public decision. We still use their words. An auspicious day was one on which the birds looked right, and an inauguration began as a consultation of the augurs.

The Greeks traveled to oracles, of which Delphi was the most famous, and they slept in the temples of healing gods in the hope of a meaningful dream. All of this was a normal part of public religion.

The sky

Astrology grew from the same root. Babylonian sky-watchers recorded the movements of the planets for hundreds of years, at first in order to advise kings. The astrology of the personal birth chart was worked out later, in the Greek-speaking world, during the last centuries BCE.

For most of the next two thousand years it was treated as a learned science, and it sat in the same libraries as astronomy and medicine. The planetary days of the week are a small piece of it that everybody still uses.

Lots, runes, and what we actually know

Casting lots is nearly as old as watching birds. Marked sticks, stones, or bones were thrown or drawn to settle a question. A Roman writer of the first century describes Germanic peoples cutting a branch from a fruit tree into slips, marking them, and scattering them on a white cloth.

He does not say what the marks were. They may have been runes, and they may not. The honest position, which our guide to the runes sets out, is that rune reading as we practice it is a twentieth-century method built on ancient letters. It is none the worse for that. It is simply not a Viking secret.

Other methods are younger than they look, and a few are older. Nobody in Europe could read tea leaves until tea arrived in the seventeenth century. Gazing into water or a dark surface, which we call scrying, is truly ancient. So is the weight on a thread: a Roman historian of the fourth century describes a ring swung over a dish of letters to spell out an answer, which any pendulum user would recognize.

Tarot began as a game

Now for the cards. Playing cards reached Europe in the late fourteenth century. By the 1440s, card makers in northern Italy were adding a fifth suit of picture cards to the pack, to serve as trumps in a new game. For the next three hundred years that is all the tarot was: a card game, and one that is still played in parts of Europe.

In 1781 a French scholar looked at the pictures and announced, without evidence, that they were a lost book of the Egyptian priests. The idea caught on at once, and within a decade decks were being printed for fortune telling. The deck that most beginners learn on today was drawn in London in 1909 by the artist Pamela Colman Smith. Our tarot guide tells the rest, and if you are picking a deck, I have written about choosing your first one.

Why the true story is the better one

I meet people who feel cheated when they learn all this. I do not see why. A deck of cards does not need to be four thousand years old to show you something true about your week. What makes a reading useful is the quality of your attention, not the age of the cardboard.

The honest history also takes away the fear. If the tarot is a fifteenth-century game whose pictures happen to be very good at prompting thought, then nobody needs to be frightened of it, nobody has to wait to be given a first deck, and nobody can tell you that your fate is fixed.

Divination, as I practice it, is a way of asking a better question. People have been doing that for as long as there have been birds to watch. It is a very long line, and a good one to stand in.